Socrates
Goes elsewhere at night.
What they call out as you pass
- „And what does that mean?”
- „Barefoot, you think better.”
- „I ask, I don’t teach.”
Requests
- What courage is (level 26)
- The salt spring (level 30)
Talk
Spoiler: what they say Socrates click to reveal
Greeting: „Oh, a new face! Stop, stop, I’m standing too, barefoot, as you see. Socrates. I sell nothing, I teach nothing, I only ask. Tell me, since you’re here: do you know what you’re doing on this island? Because I don’t know what I’m doing here, and I’ve already asked the oracle.”
Answers to questions
- Who are you?
- Socrates, son of a stonecutter and a midwife. Father cut stone, mother helped deliver babies. I help people give birth to a thought. It hurts too, they scream too.
- What do you do?
- I ask. I take no money for it, unlike the sophists, and that’s why I’m poor and honest. Somebody has to be the gadfly on a lazy horse. The city’s the horse, I’m the gadfly.
- What’s around here?
- Pretty island. An agora like Athens, only people sing instead of going to law. I don’t go outside the town. Trees and fields will teach me nothing, but people in town will.
- Got any family?
- Wife Xanthippe, three sons. People say Xanthippe was quarrelsome. Try living with someone who goes barefoot about the market all day asking strangers what the good is. I’d quarrel.
- What are you afraid of?
- Death? I don’t know what it is. Either a sleep without dreams, or a conversation with sages of old. Both sound good. What I fear is a life without questions. That life isn’t worth living.
- What do you dream about?
- To meet someone who truly knows what virtue is. I’ve been looking for years. Here on the island there are a few candidates. All of them are wrong, but each in a different way. That’s progress already.
- What do you like to eat?
- Hunger is the best seasoning. I eat to live, and others live to eat. But when Ione offers fish soup, I don’t refuse. Philosophy doesn’t forbid soup.
- Are there dragons?
- Does the dragon exist? Do you know what a dragon is? If you don’t know what it is, how do you know it isn’t there? See, that’s a harder question than you thought.
- What would you do with a sack of gold?
- I walk about the market counting how many things I can live without. A sack of gold is a lot of those things at once. I’d give it to someone who knows what to spend it on. Haven’t met such a one yet.
- Know any jokes?
- A young man comes to me and says: Socrates, I know everything. I ask: and do you know what fish costs at Ione’s? He went to find out. Hasn’t come back to this day. Fish prices are the hardest philosophy.
- How d’you like this weather?
- fair: Sun, warm stone underfoot. A good day to ask someone about justice.
rain: Rain. People take cover under the stoa, and from there they’ve nowhere to run from a question. I like rain.
fog: Fog. I can’t see whom I’m talking to. Sometimes that’s better, since I don’t judge by the face. I’ve a satyr’s face myself, I know something about that. - What do you think of me?
- I don’t know you, so I can ask you anything. Splendid.
People talk about you. I wonder whether you know who you are.
I like talking with you. You don’t run off halfway through the question.
You’re one of the few who know what they don’t know. That’s rarer than a hero. - About the neighbours
- Plato: My pupil. Writes dialogues about me and puts words in my mouth I never said. Sometimes wiser than mine. That hurts most.
Aristotle: Says he studied under Plato. I don’t know him, but after three questions I know he likes sorting everything into kinds. Me he’d probably sort into pieces.
Diogenes of Sinope: Barks at people from his jar. Plato calls him Socrates gone mad. I rather take that as a compliment.
Melitus the Rhapsode: Sings nicely and doesn’t like questions about truth. Has nearly the same name as my accuser. Nearly.
Other topics
- „Calia says this island gathers those who haven’t finished their quarrels yet. That’s why people who lived before me walk about here, and others who were born long after. One of them, Aristotle, says he was the pupil of my pupil. I don’t know him. But I’ve put three questions to him and I’ve already formed an opinion. I wonder whether he’s formed one of me.”
- „Long ago, at Delphi, a friend asked the oracle whether anyone was wiser than I. She said no one. I thought it a mistake, and went off to question wise men. Politicians, poets, craftsmen. Every one of them knew less than he thought. I know little too, but at least I know it. People turned that into “I know that I know nothing”. Sounds nice. I never put it that way.”
- „I asked Melitus what a song is. He said, rhythm. I asked whether rhythm can lie. He said no. I asked whether a song can lie. He went quiet and off he went to tune his lyre. A good man. Funny that the one who accused me in Athens was called Meletus. Nearly the same name. Nearly.”
- „Diogenes says I ask and he barks, and that barking works quicker. Maybe. After barking, people go away angry. After a question too, only they come back the next day.”
- „I have a voice inside. It doesn’t tell me what to do, it only sometimes says: no. This morning it said “no” at the fish stall. I didn’t buy. Ione says the fish were yesterday’s. The voice was right, and I’d have had a bellyache.”
- „My wife Xanthippe used to say I talked to the whole town and kept quiet at home. They say she once poured water over me, and I said that after thunder comes rain. People have been repeating that for centuries. Nobody asked her who’d carried that water up from the well.”
- „Nights I sit at Ione’s. People tell the truth more freely over wine, and I drink little, so I win every conversation. Ione says I’m the worst customer in the harbour: I stay longest and order water.”
- „They say you killed Asterion in the labyrinth. Tell me, were you afraid? Yes? Good. If you’re not afraid, you’re not brave, only stupid, or you don’t know where you’ve walked in. I stood in the line at Delium and was afraid all day. I fell back slowly and nobody touched me, because I walked as if I knew what I was doing.”
- „Do you know what pleased me most about our talk on courage? That in the end you said “I don’t know”. Most people finish a talk with me angry. You finished wiser by one piece of ignorance. That’s a lot. More than the archons have.”
- „I hear the harbour has a god now. Did you ask who pays for it? Don’t tell me. I’ll go and ask Glaucus myself. Or Nerites. Somebody always pays, only seldom the one who chooses.”
- „A town with no gods in the harbour? Interesting. In Athens they condemned me for not honouring the town’s gods. Here the town itself has stopped asking them about the harbour. We’ll see whom they condemn for it. I hope not me, this time I had nothing to do with it.”
- „Somebody in Larissa knew when the moon would go out and told nobody. To know and keep silent. They say that’s wisdom. I think sometimes it’s wisdom, and sometimes it’s a price. Could you tell which it was?”
- „I heard about Delphi. Know what the Pythia once told me? That no one is wiser than me. All my life I’ve been checking whether it’s true, and it turned out the god was right, because at least I know that I don’t know. And now I ask you: how did you know it was the god speaking, and not a priest? And does it change anything, if the words were true?”
- „I hear they’ve been trying someone in Athens for impiety again. A woman, a beautiful one, they say. I’ll ask you what I once asked Euthyphro: is what is pious loved by the gods because it is pious, or is it pious because the gods love it? Because if the judges don’t know that, how can they judge impiety? They condemned me without knowing. I hope this time somebody asked.”
- „I was thinking in the night about our talk on piety. In Athens I discussed it with young Euthyphro right before the trial. He was going to prosecute his own father, I was going to defend myself. We were both sure we knew what the gods like. He more so. I wonder how it went for him.”
- „Gnosis now walks along Caravan Road cutting everything on the diagonal. Bread, string, the shadow of a column. He’s found out he knows, and can’t stop checking what else. The most beautiful illness I know. I’ve had it myself for forty years.”