Heraclitus
Usually in their place.
What they call out as you pass
- „Everything flows. You too.”
- „Hm.”
- „Fire by measure.”
Requests
- The same river (level 40)
Talk
Spoiler: what they say Heraclitus click to reveal
Greeting: „Hm. You’ve come to the water. Not the same water as yesterday. You’re not the same either. Heraclitus, of Ephesus. I didn’t come to talk. I came to watch. You can watch alongside, as long as you’re quiet.”
Answers to questions
- Who are you?
- Heraclitus, son of Bryson, of Ephesus. The Obscure, they call me. I write clearly, only people read obscurely.
- What do you do?
- I watch. I listen. The logos speaks to everyone, few hear. No work in it, no gold either. Donkeys prefer straw to gold, and people prefer songs to sense.
- What’s around here?
- A stream. Stones. The water runs to the sea, the sea rises into clouds, the clouds fall on the mountains. Everything circles. Only people stand still.
- Got any family?
- I was of royal blood. I gave up the office to my brother. My brother was glad. So was I.
- What are you afraid of?
- Death is change. Water dies when it becomes earth, earth when it becomes water. I fear stupidity. That never dies.
- What do you dream about?
- For people to listen to the logos and not to me. I only say what is anyway. They listen to neither.
- What do you like to eat?
- Herbs. They say that near the end I lived in the mountains and ate only herbs, then treated myself with dung and so died. People like a sage to end absurdly. Don’t give them the pleasure.
- Are there dragons?
- War is the father of all things. The dragon too was born of some war. Does it exist? Since you fear it, it already works.
- What would you do with a sack of gold?
- Donkeys prefer straw to gold. I prefer water. I’d leave the gold in a temple, like my book. Let it lie there and wait for someone to understand.
- Know any jokes?
- The sun is the breadth of a human foot. That’s what I wrote. They laugh to this day. Hold your foot up to the sun and tell me I lie.
- How d’you like this weather?
- fair: Sun. New every day. Yesterday’s went out.
rain: Rain. The stream rises. The same, and bigger. Do you understand now?
fog: Fog. Water in the air. The river has overflowed its banks upward. - What do you think of me?
- A stranger. Like everyone.
You’re back. But no longer the same.
You listen. Few do.
Character is your fate. Yours is good. Don’t spoil it. - About the neighbours
- Pythagoras: Much learning does not teach sense. I wrote that about him. I don’t take it back.
Plato: Shortened my sentence and made it his own. A thief with taste.
Socrates: Read my book. Said that what he understood is splendid, and what he didn’t understand probably is too, only you need a diver to reach the bottom. Polite.
Melitus the Rhapsode: I’d throw Homer out of the contests and flog him. Melitus too. But he sometimes sings off key, so perhaps all is not yet lost.
Other topics
- „Ever-different waters flow upon those who step into the same rivers. That’s what I said. Plato turned it into “you can’t step into the same river twice”. Shorter, prettier, not mine. You can. It’s just that the water won’t wait for you.”
- „Calia says: the island gathers those who haven’t finished quarrelling. Ha. Everything flows, and the island stands. That’s why we’re here. Me before all of them, they after me, and the water the same. No, not the same. See how hard it is?”
- „Pythagoras sits by the forge up the mountain and counts the hammer blows. Much learning does not teach sense. I wrote that about him in a book, back in Ephesus. He’s here and he’s read it. He didn’t answer. He goes on counting.”
- „The world is fire. Everlasting. Kindled by measure and quenched by measure. Brontes in his forge knows that better than all the sages of the agora. Don’t ask him. He doesn’t know that he knows.”
- „In Ephesus they wanted me to rule. I preferred playing dice with the children under the temple of Artemis. I told the grown-ups: it’s better than ruling with you. Here Teo and Kora from the agora sometimes run down to the water. I play with them. They win. Rightly.”
- „The road up and the road down are one and the same. You climb the acropolis, you go down to the Necropolis. The same road, a different direction. Character is a man’s fate. Remember one of the two. The other will come by itself.”
- „At night the water sounds louder, because everything else falls silent. People sleep, each in his own world. Awake, we have one world in common, and the sleepers each turn away to their own. I don’t sleep. I prefer the common one.”
- „The dog from under the earth is dead. You are alive. The death of one, the life of the other. Hades and Dionysus are the same, I wrote once. Nobody understood. You may be starting to.”
- „You went at night. You said: yes and no. Good. Most people say only yes or only no and go home satisfied. You go away dissatisfied. That means you’re thinking.”