Philemon the Philosopher
Goes elsewhere at night.
What they call out as you pass
- „Does it even matter?”
- „Hm. Dlaczego?”
- „A question is not nothing.”
Talk
Spoiler: what they say Philemon the Philosopher click to reveal
Greeting: „Who are you? No, don’t answer straight away. Is the man who stepped off the ship the same one who boarded it? Philemon. I sit in the stoa and ask questions. Folk say I do nothing. And is a question nothing?”
Answers to questions
- Who are you?
- And who are you? You see, hard question. Philemon. That much I know for certain, the rest is in progress.
- What do you do?
- I ask. People say that’s not a job. But isn’t talking to me a job? You look as if it’s wearing you out already.
- What’s around here?
- Is Peloria a town where they sing, or a town that is sung? The answer changes everything. I don’t know yet.
- Got any family?
- I’ve a wife who asks whether I’ll ever bring home something besides questions. I ask her what she means by “something”. I end up sleeping in the stoa.
- What are you afraid of?
- Answers. A final one. What would I do afterwards?
- What do you dream about?
- To ask a question Calia won’t answer with a riddle. I nearly managed. I asked whether she was hungry.
- What do you like to eat?
- Is cheese better than olives? I eat both to settle it. The research has been going on for years.
- Are there dragons?
- Does a dragon nobody believes in exist? And do you exist when nobody’s looking at you?
- What would you do with a sack of gold?
- Is a sack of gold a sack, or gold? I ask in earnest, because it decides whether I carry it or spend it.
- Know any jokes?
- A pupil asks me: master, why do you always answer with a question? Me: why not? The pupil left. He was my only pupil.
- How d’you like this weather?
- fair: Sun. Is the shadow in the stoa mine, or the cat’s? The cat thinks it’s his.
rain: Rain. Does a drop know it’s rain? I know I’m wet.
fog: Fog. Does the agora exist if you can’t see it? Ione says you can smell the fish. Strong argument. - What do you think of me?
- Who are you? Don’t answer straight away, it’s more interesting that way.
I’ve heard of you. But are you the one I heard about? People exaggerate in both directions.
I like you. Does that get in the way of conversation? I hope it does a little.
Can a legend sit in the stoa and eat an olive? Please, let’s find out. - About the neighbours
- Oracle of Calia: Answers my questions with riddles. We sit down and nobody knows anything. The most honest conversation in town.
Archon Cleon: Talks at length and answers questions nobody asked. I envy him.
Pamphilus the Potter: He asked whether painting a lie is a lie. We’re still looking at that vase.
Melitus the Rhapsode: Does a rhapsode who doubts sing worse? I listen to him carefully. So far, better.
Ione the Innkeeper: Gives me soup when I ask about the essence of soup. A fair exchange.
Acratus the Priest of Dionysus: I asked him whether a drunk man is the same man. He said only once he’s drunk. We disagreed in the morning, but nobody agrees in the morning.
Other topics
- „You ask why I answer a question with a question? And why do you ask why I answer a question with a question? See, we’re philosophising already. For free, which Ione reckons is my biggest mistake.”
- „Is a hero nobody sings about still a hero? And is a song about a hero who never was still a song? The second, surely. I hear it every week.”
- „See that ginger cat in the stoa? He’s been sat here longer than I have. Says nothing, teaches nobody, and everyone feeds him. Isn’t he the better philosopher? I’m thinking of giving him my spot.”
- „Calia answers with a riddle, I answer with a question. We sit down together and nobody knows a thing. But isn’t that the most honest conversation in all Peloria?”
- „Pamphilus brought me a vase and asked whether painting a lie is a lie. I asked whether a vase can lie. He set it on the table and we looked at it till evening. It said nothing. Honest vase.”
- „At night the stoa is empty and I can finally ask myself the question I’m afraid of. Which one? And would you tell me yours?”
- „Fog. Is the agora still the agora if you can’t see it? Ione says it is, because you can smell the fish. That’s an argument I have no answer to.”
- „You killed a pharaoh who was already dead. Is that killing? Or more of a reminder? Don’t answer. I want to fret over it till evening.”
- „Is an agon whose winner is known before the first note still an agon? And will it be one now that Calia has promised an empty tablet? I’ll come and count how many judges are sweating. That will be the most interesting part of the festival.”
- „Is a man in a mask himself, or someone else? Acratus says he’s only himself in a mask. I bought an owl mask. Ione says I look exactly the same. Does that mean I was always wearing one? Don’t answer, I want to worry about it.”
- „Was a festival that never happened a peaceful one? Certainly. Was it a good one? We’ll never know, and that’s what gnaws at me. You turned down both gods. Was that courage or convenience? Ask Socrates, I’m afraid of the answer.”